Calling NamesI don't usually talk politics here. I have to talk politics too much for my job, and to be honest, my strongest political opinions go up to somewhere in the 17th century and then stop.
But this stuff in the news lately about Bill Cunningham introducing John McCain and taking the opportunity to emphasize Barack Obama's middle name--Hussein--several times during the introduction, while also accusing Obama of sympathizing with "world leaders who want to kill us" really bugs me. It bugs me because when I heard Cunningham defending his comments on NPR yesterday, I was suddenly, instantly, nauseatingly, back in Jr. High school.
My somewhat complicated family religious history is not that different from Obama's. He comes from a racially and religiously mixed family. I come from a religiously mixed one. We both, I suspect, spent a certain amount of time explaining ourselves to people who don't have that kind of complexity in their families.
What I remember of Jr. High school (aside from a few excruciating crushes and a set of even more excruciating dental torture devices) is how often I had this conversation.
"So you're Jewish, right?"
"No, I'm a Unitarian, but..."
"What's that?"
"Well, Unitarians believe that there's one god and no trinity, and that we should tolerate..."
"So you aren't a Christian, right?"
"No, I'm not."
"So you're Jewish, right?"
"No, but my grandparents are, and my Dad was raised Jewish and bar mitzvahed and then became and atheist and I'm a Unitarian, but I have a lot of respect for the tradition, and we do light candles for Chanukah and..."
"So you're Jewish, right?"
"...."
Now, the thing about this conversation, aside from the sheer annoyance I faced every time I was grilled about my beliefs and my family history just because I wasn't going to Confirmation class on Sundays, is that, in the Ohio town where I grew up, being asked "So, you're Jewish, right?" wasn't a way of saying, "Hey, do you happen to know when Purim is this year?" or "What'd you get for your bat mitzvah?" Or "Any chance you know the difference between a schlemiel and a schlmazle and a schmendrick?"
It was a way of saying, "So, you're different, right? And that means I should hate you and pick on you, and remind you of that difference every day, right?"
It was a way of saying, "So, I'll be justified when I draw swastikas on the posters you put up when you run for class office, because, you know, it's just *reminding* people that you're Jewish and different and weird and, you know, not like us."
It was a way of saying, "You don't belong here. And we're going to make sure you don't forget it. And we're going to make sure we won't, either."
When the kids I went to school with spent all that time trying to figure out whether to call me a Jew or not, they weren't trying to understand me. They weren't even trying to categorize me. They were trying to find a useful category for excusing their hatred of me.
And so, when Cunningham waves his hands in the air and says that Barack Hussein Obama should be proud of his name, that he's just stating the facts, and that it's those who take offense at Cunningham's use of Obama's full name who have a problem with Islam and with Obama's ethnicity, and his family's religious background, and his race...
all I hear is the kids in the cafeteria, calling me a Jew, just trying to get the facts straight, so they can decide how much to hate me.
Labels: language, outrage, politics